BACK 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
----------[Home][Previous][Up][Search][Next]


Flight Simulator 2002
 

Product Review
  
by Ben Chiu


    Quick take: With its ramp fully loaded with new aircraft and new features, Microsoft Flight Simulator 2002 is exactly what those more interested in eye-candy than greater simulation realism have been waiting for--warts and all.


    Microsoft Flight Simulator 2002 is the most visually-stunning upgrade of the world's most popular Flight Simulator series since Flight Simulator 98. In addition to an enhanced scenery engine that produces jaw-dropping visuals and a host of new visual special effects, interactive Air Traffic Control (ATC) routines, and several new aircraft are preflighted and ready on the flightline for desktop pilots.

    Screenshot Unlike some other version upgrades in this genre, Microsoft Flight Simulator 2002 (FS2K2) is more than just a cursory scenery upgrade with a few new features and new aircraft thrown in. Although its extensive new feature set may run shy of a complete overhaul, FS2K2 brings many welcome changes that should generate excitement among veteran flight sim fans and fledgling pilots alike.


      "Unlike some other version upgrades in this genre, Microsoft Flight Simulator 2002 is more than just a cursory scenery upgrade"

Once again, Microsoft has released this latest version of FlightSim in two flavors: Standard and Professional. The standard version comes with most of the aircraft that came with Flight Simulator 2000 (the Concorde remains hangared) and adds the Cessna 208 Caravan on Amphibious Floats, the Boeing 747-400, and the Cessna 172S Skyhawk SP. The Professional Edition ships with FS2K's Beech King Air 350 (turboprop) and the Mooney Bravo, and adds the Cessna 208 Grand Caravan (not on floats) and the Raytheon BE58 Baron (piston twin) to the flightline. The Pro version also includes a multiplayer 'instructor station', as well as flight dynamic and scenery tools for more serious enthusiasts and add-on developers.

FS2K2's aircraft are more graphically detailed than what was found in Flight Simulator 2000. Even the returning aircraft feature more animated parts than their predecessors. Control surface movement such as ailerons, flaps and rudder can now been seen from the cockpit, and FS2K2 now also allows the user to change paint schemes to predetermined combinations that can be viewed by other players in multiplayer flight.

Screenshot The flight modeling engine of FS2K2 is based on the enhanced FS2K version of the engine used in Combat Flight Simulator 2. As you'd expect, each airplane features its own unique flight model/performance envelope. While aircraft will still excessively weathervane into the wind, ground handling has been improved quite a bit. And each has highly detailed rendered cockpits. 3D virtual cockpits have returned as well, but only in the newer aircraft - although this time with legible, working gauges. We've always thought that virtual cockpit mode does the best job of recreating the experience of flying, and FS2K2's versions are simply fantastic.


    "Control surface movement such as ailerons, flaps and rudder can now been seen from the cockpit"

Other visual additions include things like smoke from tires at touchdown and contrails when flying at high altitude. While many flight sim fans may think these additions are really cool, from a pilot's cockpit perspective you'd hardly ever see your tires or wingtips during flight, so they are of questionable value - unless you fly or observe from an outside view at least some of the time. Nevertheless, this type of attention to detail is representative of some of the changes throughout the program.

Returning are the familiar Free Flight, Tutorials, and Flight/Adventure modes (renamed, respectively: Create A Flight, Learn To Fly, and Select A Flight). While these basic modes remain the same and Flight Sim's more familiar interface still lies beneath, virtual pilots now access them through new interface front-end screens. For example, the new front-end screen for Create A Flight now features a 'there I was' format (which should be familiar to those who fly air combat sims), where the user is able to select the aircraft and conditions of the flight to be taken. The training tutorials featuring Flight Instructor and humorist Rod Machado are virtually identical to the ones found in FS2K, and the Flights and Adventures themselves contain a mix of older (classic?) flights and new flights that feature FS2K2's new aircraft scenarios. Although returning FS pilots may have flown these old flights many times over, flying them again with the new enhanced scenery created by Autogen in FS2K2 almost makes them seem like fresh experiences.

Screenshot One of the strongest criticisms of FS2K was its poor performance, even on the fastest computers of its day (and arguable today's fastest rigs). We're not sure that this version runs any better overall in terms of raw frame rates, but considering the graphic improvements in quality and quantity that have been made while still being playable on equivalent hardware, the FS Team has done very well in this regard.


    "One of the strongest criticisms of FS2K was its poor performance, even on the fastest computers of its day"

FS2K2's flight planner is the same one that's found in the last version, and the GPS is also unimproved, retaining the same quirks and limitations as its predecessor. Real Weather - the ability to import real weather conditions into the sim - also returns. And aside from the Instructor's Station that comes with the Pro version of FS2K2, multiplayer mode remains virtually unchanged (although a few features such as DME and ADF lock no longer work). We haven't received definitive word on whether a patch is in the works (the Software Developer's Kit is what's being developed as of this writing), but in the long line of Flight Simulator versions this one has the fewest initial bugs in recent memory.

The other big criticism of FS2K was its lack of interactive Air Traffic Control. This produced a rather sterile feel to the FlightSim virtual world. To help reduce that 'empty world' feeling, FS2K2 introduces interactive Air Traffic Control and improved dynamic traffic (drone aircraft) that actually fly places now. ATC commands include ground, tower, and ARTCC (Air Route Traffic Control Center) operations. While no computer generated ATC is perfect - and no live ATC is perfect for that matter - FS2K2's ATC features aren't as accurate as what's been available in the past in competing products. Granted, FS2K2 covers the whole world while some of these other products only recreate a small section. But there are some blaring discrepancies in FS2K2's modeled ATC procedures. Some examples include ATC prompting you to send departure information to ground control (handled by clearance delivery in the real world or when contacting the tower), having you contact ARTCC's that aren't used in the real world, and vectoring you into obstacles like mountains.

Screenshot It is for these reasons that it could be argued that FS2K2 is more of a 'game' than its predecessor. We've repeatedly caught ourselves altering our flight profiles in attempts to conform with its 'non-standard' ATC functions. Doing so would of course give the appearance that FS2K2's ATC is working 'properly,' but there's the rub: disregarding the reinforcement of improper real world procedures, is this what flying sims are supposed to be about? Perhaps not. But it's a fun and welcome addition anyway.


    "FS2K2 is the perfect candidate to revive the age-old argument on what constitutes realism"

At this point you may have concluded that FS2K2 has more improvements to 'eye candy' than substantive components of the simulation, but that may not be entirely fair or accurate. FS2K2 is the perfect candidate to revive the age-old argument on what constitutes realism. The two sides of the debate argue that realism is based on flight models, flight dynamics and/or enhanced scenery. While better scenery may enhance the flight experience, some argue that scenery is not the most important feature relevant to flight simulations since this is a 'flight' simulator, not a 'scenery' simulator. Who is right? The answer depends on your point of view and what you want to get out of a product in this genre. For most virtual pilots, the answer is a resounding recommendation to buy Flight Simulator 2002.


Tip: The default controller sensitivity routines are time based rather than linear based. Instead of altering how much the control surface moves when you move the control, the default setting adjusts how much time it takes for the control surface to reach that position. To change this unrealistic characteristic, add the line "stick_sensitivity_mode=0" under the [CONTROLS] section of theFS2002.CFG file. Detailed instructions can be found at http://www.flightadventures.com/files/sim-tips.pdf


Essential Data:

Developed and Published by: Microsoft
Released: October 2002
Operating System: Windows 98, Windows ME, Windows 2000, or Windows XP (Does not support Windows NT)
Multiplayer Capability: LAN IPX, TCP/IP, Internet, or modem-to-modem

Minimum System Requirements:

  • 300 MHz Pentium II
  • Microsoft Windows 98 or later
  • 64 MB RAM
  • Quad-speed CD-ROM drive
  • 650 MB Hard disk space (minimum install)
  • DirectX 8.0a API or later
  • DirectX 8.0a API or later compatible 8 MB 3D video card capable of 800 x 600 resolution in 16 bit color
  • Super VGA monitor supporting 800 x 600 resolution in 16 bit color
  • DirectX 8.0a API compatible soundcard
  • Speakers or headphones to hear audio
  • Keyboard and mouse (joystick or flight yoke recommended)

Minimum Requirements for Multiplayer:

  • 28.8 kbps or faster modem, LAN with TCP/IP or IPX protocol, or null-modem cable
  • Internet features require Internet access.
  • MSN Gaming Zone play requires Internet Explorer 4.0 or later, or Netscape Communicator 4.0 or later.

Reviewed on:

  • Pentium III 800 MHz Processor and Windows 98 SE
  • 256 MB RAM
  • 72 GB Hard disk
  • 3D Support (GeForce2 MX)
  • 32x CD-ROM drive
  • SoundBlaster PCI-128 sound card
  • Mitsubishi Diamond Pro 21TX Monitor

Back to the top of the page

For more information join us at: http://www.flightadventures.com
FlightAdventures Magazine is best viewed at a resolution of 800 x 600 or higher.
All Content Copyright © 2001- FlightAdventures. All Rights Reserved.
Page 9